Under Mac OS X 10.6.x, NoobProof 1.4 works ok except the 'Firewall Log' button in the left side of the program's main window; clicking on it results in an error message saying that file was either empty or not found.
I emailed the author with my finding and hack solution back in May last year (2010), but I see that no new version has been released since then. Since this program is free and open source, let me share what I did to fix the little problem:
(1) download the source code and unzip everything,
(2) locate the file 'noobproof.applescript' inside the folder 'NoobProof_build_214', and open it (preferably with AppleScript Editor but a text editor will do),
(3) modify line #1349 from 'else if osxversion is equal to "10.5" then' to 'else if osxversion is greater than or equal to "10.5" then',
(4) Recompile (by opening the file 'NoobProof.xcodeproj' inside the folder 'NoobProof_build_214' with Xcode and selecting the menu command 'Build')
Netbarrier maybe easier but its a bucket of horse dung. I used to run Netbarrier all the time, but the last two releases have actually caused my Mac to Kernel Panic.
In both version 4 and 5 Intego never never fixed the problem. I would imagine 6.0 will have the same bug.
Firewalls under no circumstances should cause kernel panics ever!!
Doorstop X is the best in my opinion, simple to use and implement and does what it says on the Tin!
I've successfully used the default settings for previous versions of NoobProof, but when I use default settings for this version (1.3), my DHCP network connections attempt to use a self-assigned IP address. This represents a serious issue for support in my situation, because if default settings can be expected to cause a problem this serious, there remains no simple method for using NoobProof that I can recommend to casual users, I think.
The service entitled "System internal services (UDP)" in main NoopProof 1.3 window appears to be the one that must be enabled in order for DHCP to be successful on my system.
I've tested both 1.2 and 1.3 version and found that they do have the same problem with dhcp. I've never realized it before, thank you for submitting this bug. I agree with you, the default configuration must be friendly enough to allow a dhpc lease... :-)
I'll release a new version asap, with new features and some bug fixes. I'll set "System internal services" default rule to 'allow'.
If you look deeply into noobproof, you'll find many other bugs, that's for sure! You know, I'm alone in developing and testing this software, and it's really difficult to test everything. For this reason your help is really appreciated. Thank you.
wizard configurator is the easiest way to configure the Mac OS X firewall. It starts the first time you launch NoobProof
friendly default configuration, very simple graphic interface
injectors: deploy easily your firewall setup across a large number of macs; do backups or libraries of useful firewall configurations. Injector works on Mac OS X 10.4-10.7
NoobProof is a free and open-source application. We accept PayPal donations to hany@hanynet.com or BitCoin donations to 16UvmZcqEEYT5gYrTaGrh82d12726fQi5x Thank you.
dumbledore reviewed on 09 Sep 2011
I emailed the author with my finding and hack solution back in May last year (2010), but I see that no new version has been released since then. Since this program is free and open source, let me share what I did to fix the little problem:
(1) download the source code and unzip everything,
(2) locate the file 'noobproof.applescript' inside the folder 'NoobProof_build_214', and open it (preferably with AppleScript Editor but a text editor will do),
(3) modify line #1349 from 'else if osxversion is equal to "10.5" then' to 'else if osxversion is greater than or equal to "10.5" then',
(4) Recompile (by opening the file 'NoobProof.xcodeproj' inside the folder 'NoobProof_build_214' with Xcode and selecting the menu command 'Build')
+3
-11
iGreg reviewed on 12 Apr 2009
I found the options available convoluted with differing instructions depending on whether the firewall was on or not etc.
When I uninstalled it I followed the instructions in the order given and hope that in fact it is gone.
+2
-9
In both version 4 and 5 Intego never never fixed the problem. I would imagine 6.0 will have the same bug.
Firewalls under no circumstances should cause kernel panics ever!!
Doorstop X is the best in my opinion, simple to use and implement and does what it says on the Tin!
+3
+3
+2
I'll release a new version asap, with new features and some bug fixes. I'll set "System internal services" default rule to 'allow'.
If you look deeply into noobproof, you'll find many other bugs, that's for sure! You know, I'm alone in developing and testing this software, and it's really difficult to test everything. For this reason your help is really appreciated. Thank you.
+17
+2
Can you do a brief comparison of WaterRoof and NoobProof? Is it simply that the latter is a simplified version of the former?
hany
+59