MacApp-store only, means it's basically unusable for me since I don't use the MAS. The earlier versions worked fine, it does what it does - just get an older version.
Don't encourage the developer by buying this on MAS and give Apple 30% and your personal info for free.
Instead of "Don't encourage the developer by buying this on MAS", how about not discouraging the developer by giving a useful little 99 cent app a half-star rating because you personally don't like the Mac App Store? Are you going through all of MacUpdate marking down everything that sells through the Mac App Store, and giving 5 stars to everything that doesn't?
Next time, review the app fairly, and take up your complaints about the MAS distribution method somewhere more appropriate.
I really like I Love Stars and have used it for several months, even before it switched to the Mac App Store.
It works very well, and is the first app that really brought me to apply a star rating to most of my songs. The subtle blinking and the sound are a great “reminder“ to apply your rating now.
I would have preferred an non MAS-version as I dont’t like to wait for an Apple approved version if a new or bugfix version is to be released. But I have paid for it anyway simply to support the developer.
It never crashed on my Mac and makes me a happy camper. It would be a full 5 star rating but I have to cut a half star off because of the Mac App Store only approach.
Excellent app! I especially like the shortcut functions. If you could add one for 0 stars (unrated) it would be perfect.
It would have been nice to have this app for free but $1 is quite reasonable, the people would complain about the price and the app store have probably wasted about the same amount of money in terms of lost productivity simply by expressing their views on Macupdate.
I bought SzzlingKeys Pro (§ 4.95) just to support its developer a long time ago and I agree that it is a very good app. However, I also have a copy of I Love Stars just for the reason that it is able to assign half-star ratings what SZ still doesn't provide (as far as I know). In adition, the menu bar approach of ILS is quite nice and some of the functions of SK you don't need on an MacBook because of the function keys.
I have really enjoyed the free version of this app, and currently have version 3.4.1 on my Mac. I see no mention anywhere that this version does not work on OS X 10.6.6, but that must be the case, as it no longer launches. The developer's website no longer mentions the app at all, so perhaps he will respond on this site with information on version compatibility.
3.4.1 still runs fine on my MacBook Pro with 10.6.6 installed. It forgets to launch itself (ie I have to do it), but otherwise works just fine. Truly a terrific app.
Review is for 3.2 version...
Firstly, I am disappointed that I discovered this application too late. And by that, of course I mean the newly initiated App Store requirement. I have no issue with paying a few bucks for the app, 'tis just that I am still running that ever so old 10.5 OS X version. However, I discovered the freeware 3.2 version still hosted on that other software website .... softronic . (At least until the dev reads this review, I suppose. ;-P )
****************
In short, this application does exactly as described.
I discovered accidently that holding down the command key provides 1/2 star rating. A pleasant surprise!
On a slight aside, my Mac Mini is tethered to an Apple Bluetooth Aluminum Keyboard that has the multimedia keys. If there was some way to remap the useless brightness keys (no compatibility with non-Apple monitors) to interface with I Love Stars (or iTunes) as rating keys, I would be super pleased. My searching on remapping the special multimedia keys has been unsuccessful. Any ideas people?
This looks like a very interesting app as it might actually motivate me to listen to more than 5% of my 200GB iTunes library so I can rate it. I would love to try it but I won't be forced to go to the Mac AppStore as the sole outlet for the app. Can you even download a demo from the app store or do I have to buy before I try?
I want choices and I don't want Apple to be the bottleneck between me and software because in the big picture it gives them too much power. I don't care if it's easier for all involved, sometimes (often times I'd say) what looks like the easy path today turns out to be a nightmare in the long run.
I would think that developers would want to retain as much control and choice as possible too. What if one day Apple changes the rules of the game and removes this app because, for example, "it reproduces functionality already available" or "insert other subjective reason here"? Never put all your eggs in 1 basket!
I'm not willing to allow Apple to come between my computer and what I want on it and I hope all Mac developers will not allow Apple to become the sole distributor for their software because the long-term implications of them getting a monopoly on distribution are unacceptable to me. If that happens it will finally be time to learn how to use Linux.
To make it short: I loved "I love stars" because it's really easy to use and does what I want. I accept that the developper wants to earn money with his app. But I can't accept that I have to buy it in the Mac App Store. I won't use it, and I won't take account of any apps that are solely offered in the Mac App Store. That's why I give "I love stars" a low overall rating.
Help me out here.... I saw this upgrade to I Love Stars, so I launched my current version thinking it would advise me of the upgrade and I'd pull in the upgrade, but no such notification. So I quit iTunes and proceeded to download directly the 3.2 version. When I tried to replace the old one, it wouldn't, because the older version was in use. I tried to trash the older version but couldn't do that, it was in use. The menu bar stars had disappeared, iTunes was closed, but ILS was still 'in use.'
I'm going to restart my computer THEN move the new version to applications, but this shouldn't be required.
What did I miss/forget? 'case something like this happens again? Oh, CMD/OPT/ESC did not list I Love Stars so I couldn't force-quit. Stumped, but not done yet.
That's weird behavior, for sure. I downloaded this update...it ran for a few seconds, and then quit, disappearing from the menu bar. And indeed, the Force Quit menu didn't show it running.
If you want to clean everything out and start again, I Love Stars only seems to exist in the Application folder, where you installed it, and:
+277
Donperreault reviewed on 29 Mar 2012
-7
-9
Don't encourage the developer by buying this on MAS and give Apple 30% and your personal info for free.
+7
+24
Next time, review the app fairly, and take up your complaints about the MAS distribution method somewhere more appropriate.
-1
Giovanni-Marcucci reviewed on 17 Jun 2011
+1
+63
Martin reviewed on 16 Jun 2011
It works very well, and is the first app that really brought me to apply a star rating to most of my songs. The subtle blinking and the sound are a great “reminder“ to apply your rating now.
I would have preferred an non MAS-version as I dont’t like to wait for an Apple approved version if a new or bugfix version is to be released. But I have paid for it anyway simply to support the developer.
It never crashed on my Mac and makes me a happy camper. It would be a full 5 star rating but I have to cut a half star off because of the Mac App Store only approach.
+1
+153
Virgeist reviewed on 03 Mar 2011
It would have been nice to have this app for free but $1 is quite reasonable, the people would complain about the price and the app store have probably wasted about the same amount of money in terms of lost productivity simply by expressing their views on Macupdate.
+153
+1
+82
+1
+1
Mette reviewed on 16 Jan 2011
+43
+2
consumerx reviewed on 10 Jan 2011
Firstly, I am disappointed that I discovered this application too late. And by that, of course I mean the newly initiated App Store requirement. I have no issue with paying a few bucks for the app, 'tis just that I am still running that ever so old 10.5 OS X version. However, I discovered the freeware 3.2 version still hosted on that other software website .... softronic . (At least until the dev reads this review, I suppose. ;-P )
****************
In short, this application does exactly as described.
I discovered accidently that holding down the command key provides 1/2 star rating. A pleasant surprise!
On a slight aside, my Mac Mini is tethered to an Apple Bluetooth Aluminum Keyboard that has the multimedia keys. If there was some way to remap the useless brightness keys (no compatibility with non-Apple monitors) to interface with I Love Stars (or iTunes) as rating keys, I would be super pleased. My searching on remapping the special multimedia keys has been unsuccessful. Any ideas people?
+1
It's great that you found the 10.5 compatible version. I'll leave it alone if it helps people still on 10.5.
-8
Ikir reviewed on 09 Jan 2011
+3
+151
I want choices and I don't want Apple to be the bottleneck between me and software because in the big picture it gives them too much power. I don't care if it's easier for all involved, sometimes (often times I'd say) what looks like the easy path today turns out to be a nightmare in the long run.
I would think that developers would want to retain as much control and choice as possible too. What if one day Apple changes the rules of the game and removes this app because, for example, "it reproduces functionality already available" or "insert other subjective reason here"? Never put all your eggs in 1 basket!
I'm not willing to allow Apple to come between my computer and what I want on it and I hope all Mac developers will not allow Apple to become the sole distributor for their software because the long-term implications of them getting a monopoly on distribution are unacceptable to me. If that happens it will finally be time to learn how to use Linux.
+312
Wow it rates songs. Look at all the other projects like VLC, Sequel Pro, BowTie, etc. that provide massive functionality, all for nothing. Not a dime.
I'm not saying the developer didn't put it time and effort, but let's put this little program in perspective.
"The blind quest for cash is a fool's errand." — Tim Ferriss
+1
+99
Morannon reviewed on 08 Jan 2011
+17
I'm going to restart my computer THEN move the new version to applications, but this shouldn't be required.
What did I miss/forget? 'case something like this happens again? Oh, CMD/OPT/ESC did not list I Love Stars so I couldn't force-quit. Stumped, but not done yet.
+353
If you want to clean everything out and start again, I Love Stars only seems to exist in the Application folder, where you installed it, and:
HD:Users:(you):Library:Caches:com.potionfactory.ILoveStars
and
HD:Users:(you):Library:Preferences:com.potionfactory.ILoveStars.plist
...of course, if you had it as a login item, delete it there.
Good luck on figuring this out. I'm curious to see if others can get it to run on Snow Leopard. It won't run on mine.
-2
alexbrown rated on 05 Apr 2012
+1
Fontgoddess rated on 15 Jun 2011
rhessel rated on 22 May 2011