Gershwix

It's so simple but enough. Nice inheritance from the classic Platinum interface design. Also I'm happy to have the color variations (especially the Silver one).

Gershwix 2.5 is NOT compatible with OS 10.5 or later, since ShapeShifter, which is required to install it, is not compatible with OS 10.5. I haven't seen anything from the Gershwix author as to whether he plans an update to make a version that will work with one of the Leopard theme installing utils, nor does it look likely that Unsanity will release a Leopard-compatible version of ShapeShifter.

I love Gershwix - for me it's the best ShapeShifter theme, the most elegant in interface and integrated features. Only wish the developer would fix the Crimson/Plum mixup. Otherwise perfect.

The RIGHT theme for OSX! It's the best theme for OSX and should have been Apple's default for its OS! Fits the screen perfectly!

I really don´t know why so many people are so in love with the old mac os design. Maybe its because I was a Windows user back then, but i had to work with OS9 at the office. Really, I hated it. Since OSX 10.4 I call myself a switcher and must say, this interface/optics are so beautiful/efficent (although I replaced finder with path finder). I don´t understand why all you guys moum the old OS... But you know what you do. :) Have fun!

Basic. Pure. No BS. Aqua lays on the eye candy a bit thick, so this is a refreshing alternative.

I like it :)

Too stripey, and you might want to add a really classic apple picture instead of the fully black one, but the buttons are alright

blech, what a nightmare

From a UI standpoint it's good (most themes are horrific to use, IMPO). From an artistic standpoint I can see why other people like it, but it's not my personal style.

Great. Simple and solid. Light and hard. I think this taste is what Mac OS X's UI should have been. Strong candidate for the best "Classic Theme."