Search Mac Software Downloads
|
  Main   Members
User "poohstick" Profile
user image
About poohstick
User since Apple ][, now Mac Pro 8 core, and feeling ever more distance from Apple. I don't do brand or bling.
Last Login:17 Aug 2009 04:02
Posts:1
Reviews:1
Recent Downloads:
  1. VLC Media Player
  2. OnyX
  3. MenuMeters
  4. SimplyRAR
User Reviews


icon
smcFanControl
Aug 17 2009
****.

POOHSTICK  Re. smcfancontrol: I like Apple menu menu, but found installation not so perfect. In these days of spyware, I need every reassurance of integrity, this app seems a bit tatty (hence not so confidence building). But it seems to work well.

My use is on 09 Mac Pro 8 core on Leopard 10.5.8. I find that playing any sound roasts the CPU. The smallest sound play can cook Core A up to 90C. Internet radio (Firefox or Safari) can leave temps high (this under virgin Leopard 10.5.8) until app quit. However Quicktime Player sound causes temp jump until sound stops, then temps decline.

This seems a serious MacOS bug.

Testing with 100% load on 16 cores for several minutes only got the temperature up to 61C (no smcfancontrol).

I made 3 settings for smcfancontrol, names 1, 2, 3, ... Each higher fan settings. So I can easily boost fan as temps rise.

My setting 3 is:

EXHAUST 889

INTAKE 889

BOOSTA 938

BOOTSB 800

It would be useful if i could see my setting number in the Apple menu.

Anyone have pointers to temperature limits for Nehalen CPU?

Or links to info relating to 2009 Mac Pro sound/heat problems?

I like smcfancontrol, thumbs up to developer and I hope he continues to refine it. I'd quiet like to see a graph of historical fan speeds overlaid with temps, but perhaps this is more in Temperature monitor's domain.

Of course I'd like fan speed to automatically respond to hardware temps, but that is the OS's responsibility. Apple seems buggy or weak in this area.  
(Version 2.2.2)

praisebury
0
[ 1 Reply - Reply ]
Replies:


icon
smcFanControl
Sep 18 2009

MVANDERGRIFT  I'm glad you wrote this comment. I thought I was the only person having problems with my 2009 Mac Pro 2.93Ghz (4 core). Any sound playback through any application drives my CPU up well into the 70Cs. The BOOSTA fan does not increase to cool the CPU. I've had several kernel panics while the CPU was this hot. Intel's documentation indicates that 75C is past the safe operating temperature for the chip.

Let me know if you find any information on this problem.

Thanks!  
(Version 2.2.2)

praisebury
0


The opinions expressed in the reviews are not necessarily those of MacUpdate.
MacUpdate waives any legal binding related to the comments and opinions expressed in the reviews.
Please contact MacUpdate politely if you wish for a comment to be reviewed by MacUpdate for removal.