Search Mac Software Downloads
|
  Main   Members
User "brindsley quives" Profile
user image
About brindsley quives
Last Login:23 Sep 2009 05:07
Posts:8
Reviews:2
Recent Downloads:
  1. MesaSQLite
  2. Free Ruler
  3. CDFinder
User Reviews


icon
iPhone Explorer
Nov 18 2009

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  it's OK as far as it goes, but you should be aware that, unless your iphone/ipod is jailbroken, you're not going to see anything outside your user folder. your ipod/iphone's system files will remain frustratingly out of reach.  
(Version 1.182)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
AIM (Free Edition)
Nov 18 2009
*....

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  hangs when connecting and has to be force quit - every time  
(Version 4.0.3)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
iCab Mobile
Oct 13 2009

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  can anyone hear the sound of a dead horse being flogged?  
(Version 1.7)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
Poshier
Sep 23 2009

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  well, maybe the 'kids on the internets' were right after all, because the developers have changed the name.

now who wants to be the first to tell them how equally terrible a choice "poshier" is?

;-)  
(Version 3.0.4)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
Pagehand
Sep 23 2009
***..

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  it's a quite interesting, elegant looking and bloat-free word processor. however the main selling point; native PDF format and editing is a bit of a red herring:

sure, pagehand edits PDFs it has created itself and it saves as PDF by default. but when you consider that it can't even open PDFs created in other apps [not even in read-only mode!] and that editing a pagehand PDF in any other app with PDF editing capabilities [such as adobe acrobat] will render that PDF unusable by pagehand, you realise that pagehand's alleged PDF skills are nothing more than a bit of a parlour trick

there's nothing here that can't be achieved by using print > save as PDF from any other mac application. pagehand may save you the visual clutter of having to keep separate editable and PDF versions of your files, by cleverly combining them into one. but this single 'editable' PDF format is so tied to pagehand and so easily broken that it's not really worth the hassle.

i'd love to see a WP which did offer 'proper' full PDF editing capabilities, but the sad truth is that this is not possible, because it's not the way adobe have designed the PDF format to work. so until adobe change the format itself, apps like this will crop up every now and then promising a lot, but ultimately disappointing.

finally, the price is ridiculous for a version 1 app, when you consider the wealth of fuller-featured writing tools out there for OSX.   
(Version 1.0.6)

praisebury
0
[ 1 Reply - Reply ]
Replies:


icon
Pagehand
Oct 1 2009

RTC  As the developer of Pagehand, I have to say that Brindsley misses the point about what Pagehand is, especially when he claims that "there's nothing here that can't be achieved by using print > save as PDF from any other mac application.."

Pagehand is not intended to be just another ho-hum word processor that lets people create boring documents to send to other people who make boring edits. If that is your workflow, then Pagehand is not for you.

Pagehand is for people who toil over the visual presentation of their work, choosing just the right glyph and just the right spacing, and who want other people to view their documents exactly as intended. If you don't care about accented characters, or ornament glyphs, or kerning, or small caps, or embedded font features, or typographically correct fractions, then you certainly might prefer to use one of the look-alike word processors out there.

I should add that Pagehand offers some features that you find nowhere else. Some things are far easier to do in Pagehand than in any other word processor--for example, writing a document in which some quotes should be curled and others should not.

Expressions such as "parlour trick" and "red herring" are particularly disingenuous when one considers that the alternative to using PDF is to use a custom format that can be read only by owners of the application. Surely it is better to use a format that can be read by just about everybody than a format that can be read by only one application.

Finally, Pagehand is currently priced lower than either Mellel or Nisus, the products to which it is most frequently compared.  
(Version 1.0.6)

praisebury
+2



icon
Apple Pages
Sep 23 2009

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  apple burnt the book on user interface design, the day they implemented column view in the finder without using a separate pane solely for previewing - thus introducing us to the concept of the 'icon as a moving target'  
(Version 4.0.1)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
Apple Pages
Sep 23 2009

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  great review. and it tells it like it is. pages is another - all fur coat and no knickers - piece of software, so typical of apple these days. never mind the functionality, just keep licking that interface!  
(Version 4.0.1)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
Poshier
Jun 12 2008

BRINDSLEY QUIVES  that's as maybe. however you can't live in a vacuum and completely ignore the real world, slang usage of a term:

if you made vaccuum cleaners would you sell them under the brand name 'sucky electricals'?

would an anti-depressant called 'gay pills' attract many customers?  
(Version 1.0.4)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]

The opinions expressed in the reviews are not necessarily those of MacUpdate.
MacUpdate waives any legal binding related to the comments and opinions expressed in the reviews.
Please contact MacUpdate politely if you wish for a comment to be reviewed by MacUpdate for removal.