Search Mac Software Downloads
|
  Main   Members
User "TimmyB" Profile
user image
About TimmyB
Last Login:12 Nov 2009 16:13
Posts:5
Reviews:1
Recent Downloads:
(none)
User Reviews


icon
Apple Safari
Nov 12 2009

TIMMYB  What I am saying is that Apple should be consistent in their update policy.

They skipped a very important security update for Tiger (the recent 2009-006) but then released this new version of Safari 4.0.4.

It creates the impression that Tiger is still supported, when in-fact it is not (and continuing to Surf the web with Safari 4.0.4 is NOT SAFE)  
(Version 4.0.4)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
Apple Safari
Nov 12 2009

TIMMYB  I really don't understand why Apple made this version available for systems prior to 10.5.x

This creates the impression that it is ok to use Safari on a 10.4.x system.

Unfortunately, this is not the case, since Apple did not release a Security Update 2009-006 for 10.4.

10.4.x now has several unpatched vulnerabilities which make it unfit for use.  
(Version 4.0.4)

praisebury
-4
[ 1 Reply - Reply ]
Replies:


icon
Apple Safari
Nov 12 2009

THUS.SPAKE.Z  See above comment.  
(Version 4.0.4)

praisebury
+2



icon
Gmail Notifr
Sep 30 2009

TIMMYB  I beg of you to support 10.4.x  
(Version 0.5)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
1Password
Apr 14 2009

TIMMYB  Correction: Next to last sentence should read" "Heck, I got it for free and I'm NOT terribly thrilled with it!"  
(Version 2.9.13)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]


icon
1Password
Apr 14 2009
**...

TIMMYB  I honestly don't understand all of the hype surrounding this utility. If you use Safari then you can achieve very similar functionality by enabling Auto-Fill in the Safari prefs. Safari will then be able to save and restore your logins on almost all websites (some sites use weird login forms which Safari can't store/restore, but there are also some that 1Password can't store as well.) What's more, Safari provides true Auto-Fill of forms whereas with 1Password you must either navigate to a special menu or use a key combo to initiate the filling of the form. Safari in conjunction with the Keychain Access app (found in your Utilities folder) can also manage more than one keychain file to store your password entries. This can be configured to give you very fine control over how and when your passwords are used by Safari - 1PW only supports a single keychain file for all of your entries and simply does not offer this level of detailed access control. As a password database it is a decent app and it can also be used to store other important bits of data such as software registrations and personal info (of course there is no reason why one couldn't use the Keychain Access app to store the same info by using its Secure Notes feature. I just don't think this app is polished or versatile enough in its form filling capabilities to justify its price. Heck, I got it for free and I'm terribly thrilled with it! Be sure to throughly test it out before paying so that you know if its capabilities are a good fit for how you work in your browser environment.   
(Version 2.9.13)

praisebury
-2
[ 2 Replies - Reply ]
Replies:


icon
1Password
Apr 14 2009

TIMMYB  Correction: Next to last sentence should read" "Heck, I got it for free and I'm NOT terribly thrilled with it!"  
(Version 2.9.13)

praisebury
-1


icon
1Password
Apr 16 2009

DTEARE  I understand exactly where you're coming from; we actually hear this a lot as on the surface Safari's autofill and 1Password's features overlap. In reality, 1Password's features start where Safari autofill ends. Let me give a few examples to back up that statement.

First, Safari and other built-in browser password managers have troubles on many financial websites. Many websites have multiple password fields, disable Safari's autofill feature, use multi-step login steps, randomly generate field names, or use other techniques that often cause the standard Autofill to fail. 1Password bends over backwards to make as many of these work as possible.

Second, Safari's Autofill only works in Safari. It sounds obvious, but consider what a pain it will be if you ever switch browsers. 1Password allows you to store all your web passwords in one place and access them everywhere. With 1Password, the days of manually copying usernames and passwords from one browser to another are gone :)

Third, Safari's Autofill does not work automatically if you have multiple accounts for a website. With 1Password's menu it is very natural to have many accounts, whereas with Safari you need to manually type the username to get the "Autofill" to kick in. This behavior is quite confusing, and it is not uncommon to find "how to find your Safari login" blog posts.

Fourth, you can sync 1Password with your iPhone so you always have your passwords available with you.

Fifth, Safari fills forms on pages with URLs that are an exact match to what it has saved. 1Password offers precise URL matching so that the most relevant saved Login is selected by default, but also presents other matching Logins as options. This means if a web site moves its login page, 1Password can still log you in. In fact, 1Password can even use the information saved on a registration page to fill a form on the login page!

Of course there are more features as well but I don't want to type an entire essay here :)

Lastly, I wanted to mention you are right that Autofilling a web site when you visit it is a nice feature and it is something we're considering adding. The main reason we haven't yet is because 1Password has a feature called Go&Fill. What this does is it allows you to type in a few characters of the site you want to go to, and 1Password will take you to that site, fill in the login information, *and* automatically submit the form for you. Go&Fill is so much more convenient than Autofilling a page (where you have to type the URL and press 'login') that we've resisted adding Autofill, but I think we will end up adding it anyway as everyone has their own way of doing things.

Cheers!

--Dave Teare

Co-author of 1Password  
(Version 2.9.13)

praisebury
+3


The opinions expressed in the reviews are not necessarily those of MacUpdate.
MacUpdate waives any legal binding related to the comments and opinions expressed in the reviews.
Please contact MacUpdate politely if you wish for a comment to be reviewed by MacUpdate for removal.