ROBBY.IS.ON  "Please fix this"? Whom are you telling that? You should visit Transmission's forums and ask for support there.  
(Version 1.71)

ROBBY.IS.ON  "Perfect" would be five stars, right? :P  
(Version 1.71)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Why complain here and not ask for support on Transmission's forums?  
(Version 1.60)

ROBBY.IS.ON  With 1.52, being a Tiger user.  
(Version 1.60)

ROBBY.IS.ON  I'm also experiencing this problem. However I don't think this justifies a one-star review (it isn't a review, really).  
(Version 1.60)

ROBBY.IS.ON  It's not a question of "feature-phobia" but a lack of resources.  
(Version 1.6.7)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Oh, and please link to the thread where you reported your problem. I'd like to have a look at it.  
(Version 1.51)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Which trackers would that be?  
(Version 1.51)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Take this problem to the forums. Your comment isn't of much use here...  
(Version 1.51)

ROBBY.IS.ON  If you have found these steps of reproduction, why not report this to the developers? :)  
(Version 1.51)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Post that to Transmission's forums and I'm sure the devs will look at it. This is not a support forum.  
(Version 1.50)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Or rather http://trac.transmissionbt.com/ticket/1781. The two issues are related we've been told.  
(Version 1.50)

ROBBY.IS.ON  I've been seeing this problem as well. It's 10.4-only apparently. See http://trac.transmissionbt.com/ticket/1667.  
(Version 1.50)

ROBBY.IS.ON  ...and three stars for that! Right... oO  
(Version 7.6)

ROBBY.IS.ON  I've found the #colloquy people to be quite friendly actually. I'm sorry you experienced otherwise.  
(Version 2.2.1(4132))

ROBBY.IS.ON  You shouldn't be surprised to run into problems with so many extensions installed.

The Glims homepage even states:

"Note to Saft users:

Using both Glims and Saft on the same browser could have unexpected results. Instead of spending time inquiring and fixing this, we decided to invest our time into improving Glims so that you can ditch Saft as soon as possible. Please feel most welcome to share you thoughts with us."

I haven't tried Glims myself, so I can't rate it but giving three stars because of such a result is not really fair in my opinion.  
(Version 1.0b12)

ROBBY.IS.ON  The app seems a bit overpriced to me.

I'm sorry I can't test it as I'm on Tiger but it looks like only its aesthetics are superior compared to Sidenote (if anything all!) – which is free.

While not saying this software should be free I reckon a price in the range of 5 to 10 dollars would be more appropriate.  
(Version 1.0)

ROBBY.IS.ON  It's only one, all the more respect to him! :)  
(Version 3.1)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Try now, a silent update (2.2.1) was pushed soon after the initial 2.2 release fixing this crash. :)  
(Version 2.2.1(4132))

ROBBY.IS.ON  2.2 requires 10.4.  
(Version 2.2.1(4132))

ROBBY.IS.ON  Heavy_Shower, I thought you were quite rude.

Remember, this is not the developer's forum; this is MacUpdate, a site that lists Mac and iPhone software.

Very few developers actually look at the comments here, Berbie is an exemption. And while he/she didn't answer immediately (which you can't expect), you haven't either.  
(Version 1.8v300)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Plus, XTorrent uses an ancient version of Transmission's backend "libtransmission" without permission.  
(Version 1.1v53)

ROBBY.IS.ON  I believe the developers have stated multiple times that they will not an integrated torrent search.

You can use TorrentDam: http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/29545/torrentdam or River: http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/23981/river. :)  
(Version 1.41b4)

ROBBY.IS.ON  What makes you think this is a support forum, jwenrick?  
(Version 1.0)

ROBBY.IS.ON  First of all I thought the reviewer was *very* rude. And I think it's pathetic to create two accounts just to bash one app (Hint: everyone, look if the users "Idiotic Apps" or "clever apps" have any written any other reviews). I wouldn't be surprised in the least of "Bobby Delgato" was his third account, by the way (created just today).

Ok, there are more features than one missing:

- batch processing

- some sort of password storage

However, the developer was very friendly and responsive, removing the "annoying temp folder dialogue" in the most recent version from yesterday.

So yeah, that's three real issues in all. I can understand that someone who wants to batch process could get frustrated but still: these are features not everyone needs and I really don't think this justifies a two-star-rating.

It's silly to criticise the creator(s) of the software for the name of their company and even partly base your rating on that.  
(Version 1.7.3)

ROBBY.IS.ON  2 stars, just because of one missing feature? That's ridiculous!  
(Version 1.7.3)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Some prefer its looks (not me), its insides are outdated.  
(Version 4.2)

ROBBY.IS.ON  No voice, no video etc.  
(Version 4.2)

ROBBY.IS.ON  That was in 2005 and it was not ignored. Here it is for everyone to see:

http://trac.adiumx.com/ticket/1238.

What a ridiculous attempt to badmouth the Adium Team.  
(Version 1.3.2)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Thanks!

Let's see if it works... :)  
(Version 3.0rc2)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Same here, 0.9.2 doesn't work nicely. I've reverted back.  
(Version 0.9.2)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Of course, making suggestions is fine but the way you stated it ("half arsed, piece of SW", "It can't be THAT hard, surely?") made it look a bit like FSUES (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=FSUES) to me.  
(Version 1.2)

ROBBY.IS.ON  What's amazing to me is that this software is free...  
(Version 1.2)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Hey people, stop bashing the guy, give him a chance. I'm sure he'll soon have the website right and will tell us about the changes.

It would have been better not to release the app before getting these things done but still: it's not fair to be so mean.  
(Version 1.0b1)

ROBBY.IS.ON  I wrote a comment as a reply a few posts down, would like to add the appropriate stars. :)  
(Version 1.6)

ROBBY.IS.ON  You're wrong, it took two years, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camino#Version_history. And apart from that:

Version numbers don't say much. Even with features that were added here between 1.5 and 1.6 other developers would perhaps have given it "2.0" as the version number.

As far as I'm concerned, Camino has everything I need, it's excellent!  
(Version 1.6)

ROBBY.IS.ON  This appears to be Leopard only, doesn't start up for me, anyway.  
(Version 0.1)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Transmission is a great job.

Light-weight, functional and sexy. ;)

The developers are hard-working.

I think Transmission is one of the most impressive Open Source project in the Mac Software scene.  
(Version 1.03)

ROBBY.IS.ON  The widget looks very nice and I really enjoy it when it works.

I'm saying "when it works" because sometimes the lyrics aren't displayed ("loading..." for ages).

Also, 36MB of physical memory for a dashboard widget is too much.  
(Version 3.1.3)

ROBBY.IS.ON  50 Dollars sounds like rip-off to me...  
(Version 1.0)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Nice idea. Why don't you ask the developers to include this in the next Growl release? :)  
(Version 1.0)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Same problem here, annoying...  
(Version 1.2.1)

ROBBY.IS.ON  Thanks a lot for going to the trouble of re-releasing the app for drag&drop install. Very much appreciated! :)

I would also be interested in an option for watching non-US Amazon stores, in my case the German store.  
(Version 0.2a)

ROBBY.IS.ON  It's a pity the app is distributed in an installer package keeps me from installing it.

Otherwise, I would have loved to try it out.  
(Version 0.2)