Search Mac Software Downloads
|
  Main     Utilities     Apple MacBook SMC Firmware Updater  

Apple MacBook SMC Firmware Updater User Reviews (11 posts)Write A Review
sort: smiles | time
Dec 10 2008

MEX4ERIC  Need to load the EFI firmware first. Hope these two fix the unable to return from lid down sleep problems.  
(Version 1.2)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]
Oct 27 2006

SJJ_PUBLIC  I installed SMC Firmware 1.1 on my 2 GHz MacBook, which was *not* exhibiting the sudden shutdown problem as far as I could tell, as is recommended by Apple. There have been no issues with the update.  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]
Oct 26 2006

NYMPHE  How is it going to fix a hardware problem?

They should replace the heat sink.  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0
[ 4 Replies - Reply ]
Replies:
Oct 26 2006

GAZMAN  By keeping the operating temperature lower, it shouldn't get to the point where the heatsink is expanding so much that it makes contact with the sensor cable, causing the short circuit.

Having said that, I've had my heatsink replaced under warranty. I still installed this update. The fans seem to be spinning slightly faster at idle, which should keep temps down.  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0
Oct 27 2006

SJJ_PUBLIC  Are we sure the issue really was the heatsink? Certainly that *seemed* like a solution, but perhaps it was not the real solution or a complete solution? Perhaps replacing the heatsink only reduced the problem, with the underlying problem remaining, such that given enough high processor use it would still shut down, just requiring more than before. This is purely speculation on my part, mind you, but Apple is recommending firmware update 1.1 even for those who had the heatsink replaced (indeed, even for those with MacBooks not exhibiting the problem now.) I think it's safe to say that you should install this update. FYI, I installed it on my MacBook which was not exhibiting the problem and have seen no problems with it.  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0
Oct 27 2006

NYMPHE  Actually, I think this firmware update simply bypasses the shutdown problem. I ve seen lots of pictures, in which the cable was melted enough. Ok, fine, I am going to install it, but how should I know if my cable burns and mets inside?

If I had the RSS problem, I wouldn't use this firmware, because I couldn't demonstrate the problem again. And I don't want a notebook which has got some loose wires...  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0
Oct 27 2006

GREENIE  Incase your wondering this will only fix the issue most of the time. It doesn't always fix the issue and if the issue is not fixed then you actually need the heat sink.   
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0

Oct 26 2006

MARK EVERITT  Finally! I didn't anticipate a software fix to the RSS (random shutdown syndrome) problem. Fingers crossed now!  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]
Aug 22 2006

UZKU  now the sound from the fan finally ended, took it to get fixed to an apple store and they told me to wait for this update... great job apple!!!

without this fix, i nearly couldnt even take the macbook to libraries as it made that horrible sound (the one that looked like the fan was gonna start but then didnt... I know most of the macbook users know what im talking about)....

now we only need to improve bootcamp so that the mousepad works as in osx!!!  
(Version )

praisebury
0
[ 2 Replies - Reply ]
Replies:
Oct 26 2006

BEDOUIN  "I know most of the macbook users know what im talking about)...."

No, we don't.

Three of my friends have MacBooks; none have the moo'ing I hear complained about on the Internet non-stop.  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0
Oct 26 2006

UZKU  thats because they probably have new

If they have early versions like mine, then they should definately know what Im talking about, its a bug and apple had to fix it, it did exist  
(Version 1.1)

praisebury
0

Aug 22 2006

SHANNONRAWLS  Updated my BlackBook today because this was in the 'auto update' section. My BlackBook purchased 1.5 months ago was already as quiet as a mouse, but i updated anyhow.

Thus far...2-hours later of constant use, my BlackBook is still as quiet as a mouse. No new noises or fan spinning or anything.

I have a feeling it will simply make my fan run more efficiently on an already quiet macbook.  
(Version )

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]
Aug 18 2006

RDN2  Appears to have adjusted the maximum audio volume on my Macbook too.  
(Version )

praisebury
0
[ 2 Replies - Reply ]
Replies:
Aug 18 2006

D9  More or less?  
(Version )

praisebury
0
Aug 18 2006

RDN2  More. Not a lot but I seem to need the volume a click or maybe 2 lower than before the update.  
(Version )

praisebury
0

Aug 17 2006

ISHAN3  Stopped the occasional mooing completely after 3-4 hours of continuous use. I don't notice any baseline increase in fan noise either. CPU temps appear unchanged on average (using the Hardware Monitor app) compared to the same time yesterday at home with same indoor temp.

Nice fix, Apple.  
(Version )

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]
Aug 17 2006

NPARKER13  Is this for MBP too? Mine has been quiet, so I remain hesistant, as its also not in the software update thingie.

NP

PS, whats SMC mean?  
(Version )

praisebury
0
[ 2 Replies - Reply ]
Replies:
Aug 17 2006

MACBULLET  SMC i believe is System Management Control  
(Version )

praisebury
0
Aug 18 2006

JORY  The updater told my that my 17" MacBook Pro was not in need of this SMC updater.  
(Version )

praisebury
0

Aug 17 2006

LUTHER  I read on another forum that a MacBook user, who did not have a mooing MB, applied this update, and then he noticed his fan on all the time. Now his silent MacBook is making noise, noise from the fan constantly spinning. Just a word of warning to those without the moo who like their MacBook as it is -- IF IT AIN'T BROKE, DON'T FIX IT! I do not think I am going to apply this update because I don't want my fan spinning all the time.  
(Version )

praisebury
+1
[ 3 Replies - Reply ]
Replies:
Aug 18 2006

GAZMAN  Apparently its not just for the moos, it also makes the MacBooks run significantly cooler, especially at idle.  
(Version )

praisebury
0
Aug 18 2006

ZORG  I agree. The quiet MacBook now has a constant fan noise (though I wouldn't call it noise -- a very faint white-noise). Only really noticable when in absolute quiet. AND my MB does run cooler (was between 65 and 75C -- now constantly less than 58C; using CoreDuo Temp).  
(Version )

praisebury
0
Aug 18 2006

LUTHER  gazman - with the fan running all the time, yes, it should run cooler. But notebooks are designed to handle a little heat, and Apple originally designed the MacBook that way, so is it necessary to run the fan all the time? No. Apple is forced to make the fan all the time as the only solutioin to fix the mooing in certain MacBooks.

The question is, do you want to put up with the noise of the fan running all the time? I work in a silent environment and prefer it to stay that way.  
(Version )

praisebury
+1

Aug 17 2006

WHYTOI  Very quick update process. Some noise and two restarts and it's all done. Too soon to be aware or confirm any beneficial or adverse effects. But no repeated "moos" by the fan after 5 minutes of use.  
(Version )

praisebury
0
[ Reply ]
 

The opinions expressed in the reviews are not necessarily those of MacUpdate.
MacUpdate waives any legal binding related to the comments and opinions expressed in the reviews.
Please contact MacUpdate politely if you wish for a comment to be reviewed by MacUpdate for removal.