This is a promising app with a gorgeous interface that blows away TaskPaper and other outlining/to-do programs. The big problem is the need to go through a dialogue box to create or edit a task or note, which is yesterday's technology, and an anachronism in a program with a GUI as beautiful and minimalist as this. If the developers brought this into the 21st century with in-window task/note creation and editing, it would leave the competition in the dust, and probably boost their related cloud service subscriptions. Definitely an app to watch. I've held off on reviewing because I think the app will warrant a higher rating than I'd give it now only because of the indirect data entry issue. With that improvement, I'd give it five stars faster than, well. . .
Broken under Lion, flashes screen white when activating or deactivating Dock Gone. No response from developer in two weeks after repeated attempts. Avoid until developer responds here with a fix for Lion users.
Developer reports that Dragster has been "end-of-lifed," and will not be developed further. A shame, after a long and shaky history, for users who stayed faithful. Now looking for an alternative FTP drag-drop menu bar app.
Just got back a curt response from the developer after making a reasonable feature request: "I will not be adding this to Scrawl.
Thank You, The PAD Software Team." No explanation, nothing human. Further, both the "Stop Following" and "View this Feedback" links in the auto-generated email were dead. For these reasons and in response to some of the developer's unsympathetic and poorly reasoned responses in this forum, it's back to Scribblet for me.
Which feature request? I had submitted two. Seems as though you may need a better "UserRules" system—one that provides more thorough tracking information, at the least. Your response also doesn't explain the curtness of the reply. At what point are "votes" considered decisive? Developers also should have a say, Allen, in whether a requested feature makes sense even if it isn't popular among some arbitrary number of 'voters."The other feature, BTW, for any interested readers here, had to do with iCloud being an option. Switched off, it would disable the built in "nag screen" that the app brings up regularly, e.g., after launch, to let you know (again) that it can't make the iCloud connection. Not all users are on board with iCloud, nor should the app's developers assume that they will be. They should have the option. A final note: Three weeks after the release of 1.1.1., the update to this app STILL is not available in the App Store! All in all, an off-putting experience. A thoughtful developer would take that to heart and offer more than defensiveness, IMO.
The developer has been aware for some time that the app does NOT retain the preferences set for the icon bar (text only, text and graphic, etc.). Annoyingly, one has to rest this every time the app is launched. Shouldn't be a difficult fix, but for some reason, repeated requests to correct this failing have gone ignored. That plus frequent crashes under Snow Leopard explain the rating given here.
Thanks for bailing on your loyal Snow Leopard users. Save the rhetoric about "getting rid of the past" and "aiming for the future." May you enjoy the same loyalty from your customers that you've shown them in this move. A lousy thing to do.
Thanks for comments, Myka. Well said. BTW: My review was, and fairly, I think, a review of the developer. Especially since CW Pro is being touted as an upgrade path from CW, and since I paid to become a CW user, I felt entitled to post a review, which I expect will tend to be taken more seriously than a comment. Many App Store programs are released relatively early in their development. Purchasing is a vote of confidence and indication of faith that a developer won't pull the stunt this one pulled. In this case, again, caveat emptor.
Beta software at best. Almost no preference options, and the one that's offered (for "font family") doesn't apply or stick. Also, despite the advertised "full-screen interface," this thing won't launch in full screen by default! Don't let the incentive to purchase over the next few days before the price increases (and again a few days after that) sucker you. Not worth a nickel in its present form, and App Store-only availability, which neatly allows developers to shirk the long established try-before-you-buy practice adds insult to injury IMO. Check out FocusWrite instead. Development is virtually stopped there, but at least the app is fully realized with a reasonable set of preferences, giving the user control over the GUI. Writeroom is another option, but it's seriously overpriced, and developer Jesse Grossjean has blithely and arrogantly abandoned his customer base of users of the iPhone version (check out the reviews in the iTunes Store if you're interested), making FocusWrite by far the lesser of the two evils, and the only real minimalist, full-screen writing environment app out there at a fair price. In any case, at this point, Byword isnt' even a contender.
Thanks for your thoughts on this. Jesse also stated in his review (posted in the iTunes Store back in September after keeping users waiting four months) that he knew it "had been a long wait," and that the seriously past-due update (read "bug fixes") for WriteRoom iOS would be based on his new PlainText, which seems to have entirely upstaged WriteRoom users. That was SIX months ago, with no word since. If this doesn’t count as abandoning users, it's hard to imagine what would. At this point, and based on the many and growing number of iTunes Store reviews advising against buying WriteRoom, I think users generally would be disinclined, as I am, to put little stock in any further promises made by Jesse re: WriteRoom for iOS. You know, there are ways to do things with some modicum of consideration for those who trust you enough to spend $5 on a notepad app. One can post status updates, respond promptly to concerns about bugs, and of course, make the project a higher priority, given how many people have been adversely affected by careless coding, inadequate debugging, and early release. It’s a shame that one actually has to make a case for acting responsibly. Jesse's handling of the situation, "one man show" or not, remains the most blithely inconsiderate and irresponsible showing I've run into from any developer to date. I’ve even stopped using WriteRoom OS X in favor of FocusWrite in response to being treated so shabbily by this developer, and my sense is that many others, motivated by self-respect, have done or will do the same.
Can't support using this forum for feuding (Evan/developer vs. Steven P. Jobs/disgruntled user), but it does seem as good a time as any to submit a protest to this mass exodus of apps from independent developers to the new App Store. I ran into an out-of-nowhere bug with MenuWeather 3.1.2 as a result of which the app keeps prompting for confirmation of location on relaunch. Reported this to the developer along with my need to have access outside the App Store (10.6.6 introduces API conflicts with essential software I use), and was basically stiff-armed with, "Version 3.1.2 is no longer supported, and the App Store is the only way to get the program now." Apple has a long history of abandoning loyal users in its blithe pursuit of new (if not better) ways to do things with the OS, its own apps, etc., obviously caring little for "the rest of us" who have learned the wisdom of waiting before jumping on board Apple's latest and invariably buggy "advances," but it's disappointing to see indie developers adopting the same cavalier stance. Ergo, one star.
Looks like MU finally got around to updating the user name on posts I left previously, including some below. Please ignore the reference to "coffeenow" in my previous post.
A lean, minimalist alternative to WriteRoom at a far better price, and its only real competition. Problems: Developer responds to suggestions for improvement with the explanation that he wrote this primarily for his own use, I suppose the logic being that requests for features he himself wouldn't use are not really worth considering, and one gets the sense that the app won't be developed further. For example, I alerted him that, upon loading a file, FocusWrite momentarily "loses" the desktop curtain, which has the effect of "flashing" the desktop for a fraction of a second before the file loads. Not a big deal, but a distraction, and not a problem one finds in WriteRoom. I also suggested that the app's prefs include a way to load the last file worked on upon relaunch. Developer dismissed both ideas out of hand, the first with the comment "this is not a bug, but just how FocusWrite works," the second on the grounds that it isn't a feature he would use himself. I have no problem with a developer who writes a program for his own use putting it out there for others who may want to use it as is, but this is $9.95 shareware, and it seems inconsistent to sell the app without any real receptivity either to feature requests or ongoing development and improvement. For this reason, I'm giving the app only three stars. With a little more enthusiasm and commitment from the developer, this easily could be a five-star app, and IMO, with even just a few more of the sort of features included in WriteRoom (including better masking of the desktop and the option to reload the file that was open when the app was closed last), this would be a five-star app that would pull ahead of WriteRoom as the full-screen text editor of choice.
A sweet and honest reply from the developer, which I appreciate, and as a writer who can get diverted by techno-detours, I can relate. I went ahead and purchased FocusWrite anyway. Maybe sometime in the future, the developer will surprise us with a few improvements or additions, though I hope without too much sadness. :) Best of luck with your writing, Franck.
Be careful with this app. It interferes with system functions resulting in dictionary lookup (right-click context menu) hanging badly, and is incompatible with some other apps, e.g., Snapz Pro X, preventing screen capture of movies. Developer has been aware of the problem for some time, as I posted a review in the AS citing the issue, but has not addressed it. Not as cute as it looks, and not ready for prime time.
The app runs in DEMO mode, and is limited to syncing 10 contacts. Furthermore, after syncing, I saw no difference in either NC or Address Book. In any case, this is the second app I've seen today on MacUpdate listed as free that's actually shareware. Someone's asleep at the wheel or worse, since in this case (and the other, and who knows how many more), "free" is flatly misleading.
We must be on different sites. The URL http://www.proteron.com (link to developer's site above) continues to return 404s for purchase links, latest news, contact, company-everything but downloads. In addition a number of images show broken links. This is a poor showing: over a week to reply to a "can't purchase" alert, and the claim that the site is now up and running turns out to be wrong. Losing interest fast in this app.
Would not have posted this here if I'd been able to find a way to contact the developer on his site to report what appears to be a bug, viz., that the hot keys for raising and lowering the Backdrop don't work. Am running Snow Leopard under 10.6.3. This is a solid app that's worth following. Different feeling entirely than Hogbay Software's WriteRoom, probably the most popular of these minimalist environment writing apps. I use WriteRoom, but lost respect for its developer, Jesse Grossjean, when he dumped a crash-prone version of WriteRoom for iPhone for $4.99 on unsuspecting users in the Apple iTunes Store, then blithely ignored repeated and urgent requests for fixes from many users for months, though his site forum shows he's been aware of the problem for at least that long. (His excuse was that he was busy developing apps for the iPad. Insult to injury, that.) The experience fueled my interest in finding an alternative. Diamond's been around for a while, and with a few fixes, could be the heir apparent to WriteRoom, IMO.
"Run at startup" menu option doesn't work for me (10.6.3 on a Macbook Pro Intel Core i5); have to add the app manually under Accounts in System Prefs. Menu bar icon should be larger and less generic. Could stand a Preferences option. Still, a clean, minimalist look and well thought out workflow make for good potential here.
Having to add the app manually to login items is the problem, not a solution. The menu item provides an option to "Run Breeze at Startup" that doesn't work. It should be eliminated or fixed.
Hate to have to report it, but this latest version (5.0) has not fixed the "white background" issue on my system (a MacBook Pro 2.2 Intel running 10.6). It's a shame, as this worked fine under Leopard. The program is lovely (when it's working) and deserves to be supported via donations, but this is unusable in its current state. No idea why this white background appears and won't go away, and there's unfortunately no way to contact the developer through the Interdimension Media web site.
Updated to v. 5.0 under 10.6. Widget now shows a white background (rather than transparent) some of which clears upon clicking the "i" (info) button, but long (screen-wide) sections of it remain making the widget unusable. This is a worthy widget, but has become problematic for me in Snow Leopard. Trashing prefs has no effect.
Running 10.6 on Intel Macbook Pro. The Tabs/Misc. "Don't restore tabs if no browser window is open on quit" doesn't work. On relaunch, the browser opens the last open window even if had been closed on quit.
+2
New York Minute
Dock Gone
accountclosed reviewed on 30 Jan 2012
Dragster
+2
Scrawl
accountclosed reviewed on 15 Jan 2012
Thank You, The PAD Software Team." No explanation, nothing human. Further, both the "Stop Following" and "View this Feedback" links in the auto-generated email were dead. For these reasons and in response to some of the developer's unsympathetic and poorly reasoned responses in this forum, it's back to Scribblet for me.
+30
+30
iExplorer
accountclosed reviewed on 13 Jan 2012
+30
+6
Clean Writer Pro
accountclosed reviewed on 09 Dec 2011
+2
+30
-3
Byword
accountclosed reviewed on 14 Mar 2011
+30
MenuWeather
LiteSwitch X
+2
FocusWrite
accountclosed reviewed on 10 Feb 2011
+1
+30
PopClip
AbSync
LiteSwitch X
LiteSwitch X
Diamond
Breeze
+30
Festive Lights
+1
Festive Lights
Glims
-1
MUMenu