EDJM  Love having the small day of week and date badge in the menu bar, it looks nice and fits in well with the Apple icons. The drop-down calendar is a big plus. Thanks for updating it for Snow Leopard!!  
(Version 1.1r2)

YOUNKINT  1.1r2 working perfectly on two 10.5.8 PPC machines.  
(Version 1.1r2)

NEAL  The best of its kind. Neat. Thanks.  
(Version 1.1r2)

FOGCITYNATIVE  Wonderful little application; but V 1.1r1 does not function properly under OS X Snow Leopard.

While it doesn't crash, it also doesn't work. The calendar will pop up, the cursor is visible and it will highligght the dates or the "i" info icon used to set preferences.

But actually clicking on anyhting does not work; nothing bad happens, but it just doesn't work. The bug is confirmed here:

http://www.charcoaldesign.co.uk/bugtracker

Please if you use this software, click the link and add your vote.

And now that I don't have it, I appreciate how much I use it, so please also consider making a small donation to the author via PayPal. Once he fixes it, I intend to voluntairly make a donation.  
(Version 1.1r1)

RICHARD TAYTOR  MagiCal has significant memory leaks.  
(Version 1.1r2)

FLASH1296  Will not launch.

ERROR:

"A Cocoa NSImageCacheException was not handled"  
(Version 1.1r2)

DOUGWARD  Did exactly what I wanted to. My only issue is that when I have it just displaying the time, with the sub-pixel anti-aliasing turned off, it's very particular about where I click on it. I have to be careful to click the numbers of the time exactly or the menu doesn't show. Not a big thing, really.  
(Version 1.1)

TRONDAH  Wow, there seems to be a new version of magical every day, how much work can be done on a clock? :) No criticism though! Just funny :)  
(Version 1.1a7)

TALLIS  Works great on Snow Leopard (except it doesn't open iCal when I click on a date).

Is a great replacement for iClock that I'd been using before but is outdated.

I especially like the ability to choose the colored icon -along with any color, any font- even though Apple may have chosen to only encourage black and white (or grayscale) icons.   
(Version 1.1r2)

ERIC WOEHLER  Under 10.6.1 some prefs dont work. I can't change the text to a custom colour nor can I change the order of date/time fields. Other prefs seem to work ok. Unsure about reported memory leak - no evidence for me.  
(Version 1.1r2)