MRCRWALKER  I should follow-up on my comparison of DEVONthink and EagleFiler (below), noting first of all that I unintentionally included some misinformation there, as SJK's reply to my review pointed out (I picked up the bad info from a (misinformed) review elsewhere).

My update for those interested: I used EagleFiler for a couple months, liked it for the most part but never could get it seemlessly woven into my workflow in a way that made things more rather than less efficient. I now see greater value than I did before in the more expansive feature set of DEVONthink Pro. Because of these additional features built-in, it's proven more efficient for my needs (which include managing many "Office" files, making quick updates to Word files, managing many PDFs, scanning to searchable PDF, combining and annotating PDFs, converting text files to PDF, browsing/creating/organizing web "bookmarks," using OpenMeta tags for organization of all the above, etc, all of which can be done on the fly seemlessly within DEVONthink).

EagleFiler is a great app with (from what I hear) a very responsive developer, and it can do a portion of what I mentioned above. I think the choice between the two isn't one related to quality or usefulness in general but rather to the specific needs and workflow of the individual user. For a normally disorganized person, it's great to have more than one solid app to choose from.  
(Version 1.4.12)

STEVEN GOODHEART  Last two updates are very nice indeed. EagleFiler is one of my workhorses, and it just keeps getting better and better. If you so lots or research or are a web data miner, as I am, you will want to have this in your toolbox. I have never lost or mangled data, and I love having a good portion of my data totally available at the Finder level, not packed away in a proprietary database. Also, the support is superb. Can't recommend enough.  
(Version 1.4.12)

2COOLBABY  I have been trying all kinds of mac organizing programs and finally found Eagle Filer. I absolutely love it.

Unlike others, it handles just about every type of file and keeps it intact as that kind of file. You click on it and it opens in the default application. I have pdfs, quicktime movies, powerpoint presentations, word documents and more in it.

Despite what one reviewer said, an F1 click saves a webpage completely intact with links and all.

You can add comments and link to any other notes within the Info pane of any note.

It does have a drop pad you can put anywhere on the screen, but the F1 key does a good job of capturing things. You can also drag and drop items directly into your folders.

It has tags, smart folders and the ability to add folders and sub folders.

I really, really like this program. It has organized my whole chaotic life.

Unlike most other note programs, this one will work in Tiger and Leopard.

Things they could improve on:

Add a .mac sync or an easier way to backup to programs like dropbox. There is a way, but I am having to learn it. It could be a lot easier.

Pretty up their icon. It kind of looks like an OS 9 icon.

Neither of these things is a deal breaker for me, since I am finding this to be an awesome program.  
(Version 1.4.9)

ONEBLESSEDGUY  I am just starting my 30 day trial. I love how easy it is so far. It made short work of my old emails that I was storing locally. One question. Would you suggest using EF for all of my IMAP Gmail as well?

Lastly, and I'm just being constructive, you need a new icon. It just doesn't make me want to keep it in my dock. Sorry. Any hope of a new one soon?

I couldn't find this but does the license allow me to use it on my home and work keeping in mind the concurrent use clause?

Thank you!  
(Version 1.4.9)

XPLICIT  Missing a floating drop-thingy, like Yojimbo or DevonThink have.   
(Version 1.4.7)

MRCRWALKER  Eaglefiler is a terrific app. for organizing the thousands of documents and thousands more other types of files on my Mac.

I have tried virtually all of the document management apps available (e.g. DevonThink, Journler, YoJimbo, etc.) and they are all different, but the two seriously functional apps in this group are DevonThink (DT) and Eaglefiler (EF). Two things made me choose EF over DT Pro:

1) EF can handle many more types of files than DT can, and

2) it doesn't store the docs it handles in an SQL database that can't be accessed from the Finder (like DT). The latest version of DT can "index" files rather than copy them into its database, but DT doesn't perform very well if you try to "index" a significant quantity of docs (the developer admits the indexing function wasn't designed to be the primary means of bring files "into" DT).

DT Pro Office, as a suite, has more features than EF, but most of those are already easily handled otherwise in my case, and of course it's more expensive. Although I'm still learning EF, it does seem that the "AI" searching and auto-indexing of DevonThink are superior to the search functions in EagleFiler, which are themselves far superior to the functionality of Spotlight. But what both apps can do, EagleFiler tends to do them better. Add to that the two points above, and Eaglefiler was the winner for my own needs.  
(Version 1.4.6)

TEKSESTRO  I intended to use of EagleFiler as an email archival program. As such, I expected that the program would enable me to effectively archive old messages, while enabling me to search through and access them as needed, in the future. Unfortunately, the program seems to be impossibly slow when dealing with reasonably large amounts of email data, which renders it useless to email archival purposes.

My email database has over 50,000 messages, which I've accumulated only in the last 3 years. Exporting these messages from Mail is in itself a chore, as the Mail functions choke on mailboxes that contain over 3,000 messages. Because of that, when exporting truly large mailboxes - such as my 'Sent' or 'Inbox' boxes - I have to 'break down' the export into several .mbox files, each containing less than the 3,000 maximum number of messages. As a result, for large mailboxes, I end up with a series of files - "sent_1.mbox", "sent_2.mbox", etc. - which then will have to be re-compiled together by the importing program. In total, I exported about 20 mbox files, which I then proceeded to import into EagleFiler.

Importing and re-assembling the mailboxes in EagleFiler took over 16 hours in total. Although EagleFiler seems to import an mbox file quite quickly, it has no function to allow you to merge mailboxes. Therefore, the only solution is to create a new folder, and move all of the email messages from the individual mailboxes into that folder. Should be a simple operation, but when selecting and dragging 3,000 messages, EagleFiler would make me wait up to 4 minutes on my MacBook with a spinning beachball before giving me any visual feedback that it had not crashed. Actually transferring each message from the imported mailbox into the new folder takes a lot longer.

Trying to save time, I would try to perform 2 transfers simultaneously. Both transfers would start, and continue for a while, but without fail, eventually one of them would 'get stuck' while transferring a message, and then the whole program would freeze with a spinning beachball. After about 15 minutes waiting for the program to try and recover itself, I would have to force-quit it, re-open it, and start the transfers again.

Once all 50,000 messages were transferred, I found that actually using the program was nearly impossible, due to endless waits and lags that appear everywhere:

* opening the program takes over 2 minutes, with no visual feedback given that anything is happening

* every time the program opens, it checks the entire database to see if it needs re-indexing - this leaves the program unresponsive and sluggish for anything up to 6 minutes

* trying to view *any* single email brings up the spinning beachball, and a delay of about 10-15 seconds

In summary: EagleFiles seems to be absolutely useless when dealing with large amounts of data. It seems that a lot more optimisation needs to happen on the code, before the program can be of any use for longer-term archival of email or other large quantities of data.

It seems to me that this application was designed to 'collect' together a SMALL amount of information, such as documents, pictures, emails, and random bits of information that might belong to a project. At those tasks, it may do an acceptable job, although other, older and more feature-full apps exist that already fill that market - such as DevonThink. As an email or large archival/data storage utility, it fails miserably.  
(Version 1.4.5)

MYSTERY TRAMP  Fine program. Crisp interface. It does an excellent job. I deal with a lot of files with ".ged" extension, and EagleFiler recognizes them as text files, and displays them correctly.

Two quibbles. One, the help file says it reads Bean documents, but the ".bean" docs I've imported aren't displayed.

Two, I think $40 is a little rich for my blood, but I may have to break down and bite the bullet.

Nice job.

mt  
(Version 1.4.5)

KLAGRECA  EagleFiler is an example of why the MacOS platform is the greatest system. This application is amazing.

EagleFiler has helped me organize my stuff by effectively extending the OS -- not replacing it. I can still find my PDFs and other documents through spotlight, or I can navigate my stuff through EagleFiler. That's a big plus.

The features of Eaglefiler are designed to maximize efficency while not complicating my life. Web page? No problem. PDF? Indexes it. Need to add tags? Yup. EagleFiler takes care of everything I need to ever file.

Finally, the software is regularly updated with new features, improvements and fixes.

Hearty thanks go out to Mike. You've helped me simplify my life!   
(Version 1.4.5)

STEVEN GOODHEART  EagleFiler continues to be one of the best and most useful programs I own and use every day -- and the updates and improvements keep on coming. I am especially happy about the new ability to recognize and import tags that are stored in a file’s extended attributes, for use with my tagging programs like Punakea. Also, being able to import from a Smart Folder is a way cool improvement that I immediately find useful. Support from Michael Tsai is as good as I've ever had with any Mac software I've used. Can't recommend EagleFiler enough. Steve  
(Version 1.4.5)