








(1)
Your rating: Now say why...


| Downloads:5,708 |
| Version Downloads:3,321 |
| Type:Multimedia & Design : Animation |
| License:Free |
| Date:07 Nov 2009 |
| Platform:PPC / Intel |
| Price:Free |
Overall (Version 1.x):![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Features:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Ease of Use:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Value:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Stability:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
+4
Kihoalu reviewed on 01 Mar 2011
MakeHuman might one day become viable, but it has some quirks that make it a problem. The price is right, though.
The models can be dropped into Blender as *.obj files. But they aren't very usable once you get there. The right-left designation is the opposite of what Blender 's is (model right & left which facilitates mirroring).
Fingers & Toes are too complex.
Poser though, is NOT an alternative to MakeHuman, either.
Unless you want Barbies to drop into another program.
+76
1. It's not even a beta --- the description in MUD is a statement of direction of the ***open source project***--- not of the existing software ---- so reduce your expectations bigtime.
2. From the Quick Start docs: "This is not a full-function release--The purpose of this Alpha 1 release is to encourage feedback on the features and their usability via the MakeHuman community forums."
3. It will/does require a 3rd party rendering program to export to/integrate with in order to save/print/etc.
4. Currently it resembles a severely crippled shareware --- instead of "look what I can do once you pay your $$$" --- it's "look at what I should be able to do later". What is there does look good.
5. "What's new"?
--- Hair Tool just shows a small variety of hairstyles in the corner. No clue as to how to move/use them.
--- Installer. Perhaps for the other platforms. For the Mac, it's just an app.
--- Renderman Curves? Again no clue.
6. Docs are also a work in progress.
As it appears the user is restricted from saving, exporting to another graphics program or even printing the image without major distortions I don't see this as serving much of a purpose apart from the occasional doodling on screen. Why dedicate 120MB of precious disk space to such a paltry performance?
A lot of good work has gone into MakeHuman, but it's of little use beyond a novelty.
For anyone wishing to use such programs seriously I'd suggest you pay the money for one of the comprehensive applications on the market or take a few life drawing classes and create your own imagery.
But thanks for the mighty effort.