BootPicker... With the advent of Boot Camp comes the possibility of deploying multi-boot Macs and permitting your end users to choose whichever platform will work best for whatever they'd like to do at the moment. But how do you manage the presentation of this choice? There are a couple concerns to keep in mind:
Setting the boot device is an activity restricted to administrative users.
Allowing non-administrative users access to this functionality potentially allows them to set the boot device to some external media that they provide (then they can really tamper with
What's New
Version 2.1.2: Added some accessibility features. VoiceOver and keyboard interaction are now supported.
Requirements
Intel, Mac OS X 10.4 or later, Intel Mac.
Option, option, option... STOP telling us about holding the option key. We Mac users expect a more elegant way to choose the startup. Sitting attached to the keyboard holding the option for 20 seconds at every restart (yes, sometimes we forget what the boot is set for, so we better sit at the keyboard and hold... and hold) is not the best solution.
Unfortunately, BootPicker is no better. This is the most useless piece of software I have ever seen. It does not change the actual ROM setting for startup. It always boots to OS X first, and presents a picker screen just before user login should appear. Even when I am in Windows, and use BootCamp control panel to choose to boot to OS X, this thing STILL halts the startup of OS X and presents its cotton picking picker screen. That is no better than holding the option key.
For those of us needing OS X to have write support for a Windows 7 partition, NTFS-3G needs to add a System Preferences pane like that of "NTFS For Mac" that allows you to choose the writable NTFS partition with Windows 7 as the startup. Until that happens, NTFS For Mac is the best method of having NTFS write support AND a fairly elegant way to set the startup disk.
You clearly did not read what the developer has in mind, he says:
Leaving the machine at the EFI boot picker (hold down the option key at startup), while possible, leaves the previous options open and also leaves the machine in a state in which it cannot be managed or accessed via the network.
This clearly shows he knows about the option key, but wants more functionality than that. Whether a single user needs that is open for debate, but clearly he is talking about managing the boot-up of several Macs in a lab environment.
Unless you are using more than Windows and OS X on an Intel Mac, I don't really see the value of this software. AFAIK, you cannot set a firmware password on an Intel Mac since it uses EFI as opposed to the Open Firmware of previous G-series Macs. Just press the Option key on startup and you will be presented with icons for booting into either OS X or Windows XP, even multiple versions on different partitions/disks if available, using no additional boot-picker software (such as this).
"Intel-based Macintosh computers can be protected by firmware passwords as well. The firmware in an Intel-based computer uses Extended Firmware Interface (EFI) technology-Open Firmware is used in computers that use PowerPC processors.
All Intel-based Macintosh computers support firmware password protection."
Although not installed by the Install Disks, Open Firmware Password.app is present on the disks that came with my MacBook. I used Pacifist to install it into my Utilities folder where it works like a charm.
I was doing some remote sessioning with my windows, and since I would need to restart a few times, I set BootPicker to default to WinXP. now, I can't boot into OSX! Is there a way to be able to get in and uninstall it?!
I've already tried:
a) holding in Option key and choosing Mac - BootPicker loads after Mac login window appears..
b) logging into Windows, and choosing "Boot into Mac" from BootCamp..
Please login or create a new MacUpdate Member account to use this feature
Watch Lists are available to MacUpdate Desktop Members Upgrade Now
Download and auto-install
using MacUpdate Desktop. Save
time moving folders and cleaning-up.
BootPicker... With the advent of Boot Camp comes the possibility of deploying multi-boot Macs and permitting your end users to choose whichever platform will work best for whatever they'd like to do at the moment. But how do you manage the presentation of this choice? There are a couple concerns to keep in mind:
Setting the boot device is an activity restricted to administrative users.
Allowing non-administrative users access to this functionality potentially allows them to set the boot device to some external media that they provide (then they can really tamper with the system).
Leaving the machine at the EFI boot picker (hold down the option key at startup), while possible, leaves the previous options open and also leaves the machine in a state in which it cannot be managed or accessed via the network. rEFIt allows you to lock down the boot options at startup, however you're still unable to actually manage the machine in this state.
Before developing BootPicker, I came up with a list of requirements that I would insist upon were I to manage a lab of dual-boot Macs:
Must work when a firmware password is applied to the machine
The boot picker cannot interfere with remote administration (e.g. via ARD)
The boot picker must allow the administrator to specify explicitly which drives are permitted as boot devices
The administrator can disable (remotely) the boot picker at any time
When the machine is rebooted, it will always boot to Mac OS X by default and present the boot picker
Optionally, the boot picker preferences can be managed via directory services (permits management at a large scale)
Optionally, the boot picker should allow the administrator to provide some guidance to the end user about why they should choose one OS over another
BootPicker satisfies all of these requirements. BootPicker runs on startup immediately prior to LoginWindow. Based upon your configuration, it presents an option to the end user to choose an operating system. Upon choosing that OS, the machine either continues to Mac OS X or reboots to the specified OS. The next time the computer is rebooted, it automatically returns to Mac OS X and the boot picker. Finally, for environments that require management at a large scale, or management while the machines are turned off or booted to a different OS, BootPicker can be managed via a Mac OS X Server Open Directory Master. Got AD? That's OK, you can leverage that as well. You can even run BootPicker from a logout script to give every new visitor to your lab machines the opportunity to choose their OS without rebooting.
BootPicker is free as in beer and free as in speech. That means there's no charge to use it and even the source code is available. If you'd like to tweak, modify, localize, or just peek at the source code to BootPicker, you can browse the source here or download via subversion as indicated at the Bombich Software Sourcecode Repository.
+2
Lance_baker reviewed on 30 Aug 2010
Unfortunately, BootPicker is no better. This is the most useless piece of software I have ever seen. It does not change the actual ROM setting for startup. It always boots to OS X first, and presents a picker screen just before user login should appear. Even when I am in Windows, and use BootCamp control panel to choose to boot to OS X, this thing STILL halts the startup of OS X and presents its cotton picking picker screen. That is no better than holding the option key.
For those of us needing OS X to have write support for a Windows 7 partition, NTFS-3G needs to add a System Preferences pane like that of "NTFS For Mac" that allows you to choose the writable NTFS partition with Windows 7 as the startup. Until that happens, NTFS For Mac is the best method of having NTFS write support AND a fairly elegant way to set the startup disk.
-6
+15
+114
-3
-6
Convergencesite
+1
+2
Leaving the machine at the EFI boot picker (hold down the option key at startup), while possible, leaves the previous options open and also leaves the machine in a state in which it cannot be managed or accessed via the network.
This clearly shows he knows about the option key, but wants more functionality than that. Whether a single user needs that is open for debate, but clearly he is talking about managing the boot-up of several Macs in a lab environment.
+1
+4
+3
"Intel-based Macintosh computers can be protected by firmware passwords as well. The firmware in an Intel-based computer uses Extended Firmware Interface (EFI) technology-Open Firmware is used in computers that use PowerPC processors.
All Intel-based Macintosh computers support firmware password protection."
Read entire article here:
http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=106482
+110
+1
+5
A J Benamu reviewed on 02 May 2007
I've already tried:
a) holding in Option key and choosing Mac - BootPicker loads after Mac login window appears..
b) logging into Windows, and choosing "Boot into Mac" from BootCamp..
weftech rated on 17 Jan 2012