








(8)
Your rating: Now say why...





(8)


| Downloads:12,969 |
| Version Downloads:4,497 |
| Type:Games : Card & Board |
| License:Shareware |
| Date:22 May 2007 |
| Platform:PPC / Intel |
| Price: $20.00 |
Overall (Version 1.x):![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Features:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Ease of Use:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Value:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Stability:![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
+22
Trail Walker reviewed on 25 Jul 2010
Did not allow Mahjong for completing a sequence (with an existing hidden chow and pair).
Occasionally does not allow a chow for discard of previous seat.
I have played with many rule-sets, but malfunctions of this program are extraordinary --- profoundly STUPID.
minor objection: does not retain a display of previous discards
+1
+22
Note: if the difficulties involved only interface or haphazard crashing, then I would have sent email to developer. Since the misbehavior is deeper, I opted to alert those of us who play the real game (as opposed to clones of Brodie Lockard's Shanghai).
+2
+22
Trail Walker reviewed on 25 Jul 2010
Did not allow Mahjong for completing a sequence (with an existing hidden chow and pair).
Occasionally does not allow a chow for discard of previous seat.
I have played with many rule-sets, but malfunctions of this program are extraordinary --- profoundly STUPID.
minor objection: does not retain a display of previous discards
+1
+432
+1
+432
I ran across additional problems/bugs.
When i chose "Simple Custom" in the prefs, without have installed any, i got one of the default boards with absolutely no controls.
I couldn't get back to the menu and had to quit from the menu. But when i reran the app, choosing to begin a new game gave me game sounds while the window continued to display the menu.
Since the first run, every time i start up the app and to go Options, the menus are displayed improperly, as i described in my previous post.
Also, it would be helpful if the Options screen displayed the true appearance of the tiles and boards.
.
+432
Woops. That line in my post should have read:
I couldn't get back to the Menu display and had to quit from the menubar or Dock menu.
+1
+432
Corpsecorps reviewed on 23 Jun 2007
Game play and options have been improved significantly over version 1.3 - the last time i checked in.
It could still use far more variations and traditional terminology for less of an Americanized feel.
I've not had any problems with crashes, but there are display glitches. After playing several games, when i returned to options, the text on pull-downs was sagging off the bottom, and when i clicked them, the menus appeared too low also, and detached.
I'm still not thrilled with the UI by any means. Graphics are just odd and not particularly eye-catching or pleasing. The highlight animations are distracting, and the sounds are a bit annoying.
With system volume only half-way up, the staccato clack of pieces was ear piercing through headphones unless game volume was also less than half-way up.
Over all, while reasonably playable, MahJong Tradition has a late alpha feel to it instead of the solid unified tone of a $20 final version.
.
+1
+3
amcan12 reviewed on 19 Jun 2007
And because game is taking over your screen completely (no windowed mode) the only way to get out of any crash is to hard restart your Mac. Absolutely unacceptable behavior.
Other glitch is lack of option to set custom sound volume and speed of game as default - every time game is restarted player must manually adjust volume and speed - and this is when most crashes occur as game is already in play.
IMHO game nehaves like in beta stage, not worth paying for until major fixes are done.
Amcan12 is the only person reporting that the game crashes - under any circumstances.
No windowed mode? MJT fully supports fullscreen and windowed modes; at whatever resolutions their monitor can handle. I've even programmed a keyboard shortcut to quickly switch between the two modes.
Game speed and sound volume can be permanently set in Options. They can also be temporarily changed during a game.
MahJong Tradition is far removed from any kind of beta stage of development. While people might disagree with my artistic choices or my (dubious) talents at creating custom music, such a devastatingly-negative review might discourage people from trying the game out; which would be a shame.
+1
+5
Impish reviewed on 30 May 2007
One major bug, however: the game often misses potential Chows and bypasses me without giving me the chance to declare them. This is so even when I have precedence, as when no other player wants the tile, and one time, even when the chow would have allowed me to Mahjongg (the highest precedence of all). I've tested this repeatedly and in different ways, such as playing an All-Chow game. Even tho' precedence was now turn-based (no Pungs or Kongs allowed), the game didn't notice Chows available in my tray even when I was next in turn.
I've been trying to determine if there is a pattern to the missed Chows. For example, are the missed ones always the middle tile in the sequence (I have a 5 and 7 coins, and the discard is the 6-coin). But no, the program has missed middle and end tiles.
The bug is intermittent-- it does catch some chows -- but frequent enough to occur several times in each games.
So for now, I'm playing All-Pung games, which so far, the app has never missed.
Once this problem has been fixed, we'd have a true-blue Mahjongg game for the Mac.
Ed Stoudenmire reviewed on 02 Feb 2007
As someone who has never physically played MJ outside of a computer, I must say I've learned a lot about the game from watching this one play.
I disagree with those who say the UI is bland or gruesome. It could be better; this is v 1.4.
The gameplay could be improved, I'm sure. V 1.4.
The graphics problems and the tile designs and the speed settings and the discarded tiles... VERSION 1.4!!
Come on, people, don't beat up on the guy for an imperfect product. It's a good base on which to build. Try contacting the guy with ideas. He's proven to be quite receptive and very pleasant to exchange emails with.
Mah Jongg game for OS X. My family has enjoyed this wonderfull game for years.The last time I counted,
I have collected 13 Mah Jongg sets. My wife hosts
a Monday Mah Jongg group and she plays the old
Mah Jongg Parlor on OS 9 every day. We downloaded
this game today, played it and gladly paid for it at
once. It's not perfect, but it is 100% better than any
other true
Mah Jongg game for OS X of which there are none.
+1
+432
I forgot to mention that on my Mac Pro in windowed mode, display options are appearing at the very bottom of their pull-downs, or sometimes bleeding off.
(This really should not have been called MahJong Tradition, since it's a very bland tradition-free version.)
+1
+12
+432
Corpsecorps rated on 31 May 2011